Buy Winstons Beds hand-stitched pocket spring mattress, Double, Kingsize, Super king at
British Handcrafting Heritage

Winston's Beds
30 Year Guarantee

Buy Winstons Beds hand-stitched pocket spring mattress, Double, Kingsize, Super king at
100 Night-Trial

star icon
5 Star Reviews

Stearns and Foster Mattress Review 2024

Dive into our comprehensive Stearns and Foster mattress review guide to discover why Stearns and Foster doesn’t match up to the unparalleled luxury of Winstons Beds. By exploring the details below, you’ll understand why choosing Winston’s Beds over Stearns and Foster represents a wise decision for those in pursuit of a true luxury mattress experience, as opposed to settling for a mid-range foam mattress. Learn what sets Winston’s Beds apart and make an informed choice for supreme comfort and quality.

What is the review guide about?

In this review guide, we will explain the key features that define a luxury mattress, including how a luxury mattress is constructed, the types of fillings considered high-end and the variety of spring types available. Additionally, we will provide comparisons and alternatives to Stearns and Foster mattresses. It’s important for customers to familiarise themselves with the fundamentals of luxury mattresses before exploring these comparisons and alternatives. This knowledge will enable them to understand why our mattresses, regarded as the most luxurious in the world at the fairest prices, are a preferable choice over a Stearns and Foster foam mattress.

What are the essential characteristics of a luxury mattress?

Natural Fibre Content

A luxury mattress must be 100% natural to embody the pinnacle of comfort, healthiness and environmental friendliness. Natural fibres like wool, horsehair cotton and silk outperform synthetic materials such as foam in breathability, ensuring a temperature-regulated sleep environment. They also offer superior durability, maintaining their structure and comfort over time, unlike foam, which can degrade and lose support. Moreover, natural materials are hypoallergenic and free from chemicals, making them healthier for sleepers and the planet. Given these benefits, a luxury mattress commands a higher price, reflecting the quality, sustainability and craftsmanship involved in using natural fibres, whereas foam mattresses, lacking these premium attributes, should not cost as much.

  • Does Stearns and Foster adhere to these standards? –  No
  • Does Winstons Beds adhere to these standards? – Yes
Types of Fibres Used

Wool, Cashmere, Silk, Horsetail, Flax, Coir, Cotton

  • Does Stearns and Foster adhere to these standards? –  No
  • Does Winstons Beds adhere to these standards? – Yes
High GSM of Fibres

GSM, or Grams per Square Meter, measures the density of fibres in mattress fillings. A higher GSM indicates a denser filling, which directly impacts the mattress’s comfort, support and durability. When a mattress has a higher GSM, it means there are more fibres packed into each square meter, resulting in a plush, supportive sleep surface. This density not only provides a luxurious feel, cradling the body for enhanced comfort but also offers substantial support, ensuring even weight distribution and proper spinal alignment. Moreover, denser materials tend to maintain their structure and resilience over time, making the mattress more durable and resistant to wear and tear. Consequently, as the GSM increases, so does the cost of production. High-GSM materials are typically more expensive due to their quality and the enhanced benefits they offer, leading to a higher price point for the finished .

  • Does Stearns and Foster adhere to these standards? – No, because they use foam
  • Does Winstons Beds adhere to these standards? – Yes, the highest in the world at each price point
Hand Stitched

Hand stitching in mattresses involves the artisanal process of sewing the layers of a mattress together manually, using a needle and thread. This method is highly detailed and allows for precise control over the mattress’s construction. Unlike machine stitching, hand stitching is carried out by skilled craftsmen who apply their expertise to ensure each stitch is perfectly placed. This technique not only secures the mattress layers together but also adds to the overall aesthetics, giving the mattress a distinctive, luxurious appearance. The meticulous nature of hand stitching contributes to the mattress’s enhanced durability and comfort, making it a hallmark of quality in luxury bedding.

  • Does Stearns and Foster adhere to these standards? – No
  • Does Winstons Beds adhere to these standards? – Yes
Spring Type

Calico pocket springs represent the epitome of luxury in mattress design, being hand-tied with twine and encased in natural calico fabric. This unique construction allows for exceptional breathability, independent movement of each spring for targeted support and reduced motion transfer. These features distinguish calico pocket springs as superior to other types, offering unparalleled comfort and durability. Prestigious brands like Winstons, Vispring and Savoir use them, highlighting their luxury status.

  • Does Stearns and Foster adhere to these standards? – No
  • Does Winstons Beds adhere to these standards? – Yes

What type of springs do Stearns and Foster and Winstons Beds utilise?

Calico Pocket Spring

The calico pocket spring system stands out for its exceptional craftsmanship and luxury. Each spring is individually hand-tied with twine and encased in breathable, natural calico fabric, allowing for independent movement and superior responsiveness. This design offers precise body contouring and support, reducing pressure points for improved sleep quality. Renowned for its use of high-quality materials and meticulous construction, the calico pocket spring is considered the most luxurious spring type in the world, appealing to those seeking premium comfort and sustainability.

  • Approx cost to produce: 1600 calico spring unit in queen mattress $350
  • Do Stearns and Foster use this spring: No
  • Do Winstons Beds use this spring: Yes
Spunbond Innerspring

A spunbond innerspring system utilises mattress springs wrapped in spunbond fabric, a cost-effective material that helps maintain the structure of the mattress. Common in mid-range mattresses, this setup offers basic support and comfort. However, compared to calico pocket springs, which are individually wrapped and hand-tied for superior responsiveness and comfort, spunbond innersprings fall short. They lack the same level of luxury and precise body support, making them less ideal for those seeking the highest quality sleep experience.

  • Approx cost to produce: 2000 innerspring unit in queen mattress $132
  • Do Stearns and Foster use this spring: Yes
  • Do Winstons Beds use this spring: Yes
Micro Coils

Micro coils are thin, small springs used in mattresses as a cheaper alternative to comfort fibres. Though they add support, they lack the plushness and durability of more luxurious materials. This substitution often leads to compromised comfort and longevity, making micro coils an inferior choice for those seeking a high-quality sleep experience.

  • Approx cost to produce: 2000 micro coil layer $35
  • Do Stearns and Foster use this spring: Yes
  • Do Winstons Beds use this spring: No

Why does foam not qualify as a luxurious mattress filling?

Foam, despite its widespread use in mattresses, does not hold the same luxurious status as natural fibres. This distinction stems from several factors, including the materials’ composition, manufacturing processes and inherent qualities.

Foam mattresses, often made from polyurethane and other chemicals, offer practical benefits like affordability and adaptability to body shape. However, these chemicals raise concerns about environmental impact and indoor air quality. Off-gassing, a process where volatile organic compounds (VOCs) release into the air, can cause unpleasant odours and potential health risks. This aspect contrasts sharply with natural fibres, which boast eco-friendliness and non-toxicity, enhancing their luxury appeal.

Moreover, the production of foam is cost-effective, making it a budget-friendly option. Its affordability is due to synthetic materials’ lower production costs and the simplified manufacturing process. While this makes foam mattresses accessible, it also places them in a different category from luxury products. Luxury items, by definition, are often associated with higher costs, reflecting premium materials and craftsmanship. Natural fibres like wool, silk, horsehair and cotton, demand intricate processing and sourcing, factors that contribute to their luxurious and exclusive nature.

Natural fibres also excel in comfort and durability, surpassing foam in breathability and moisture-wicking properties. These characteristics ensure a cooler, more comfortable sleep environment, free from the heat retention commonly experienced with foam. Additionally, natural fibres offer better longevity, maintaining their shape and functionality over time without the sagging and compression often seen in foam mattresses.

Stearns and Foster reviews

Key Complaints in Stearns and Foster Mattress Review

Issue Description
Sagging and Indentations Many customers report early sagging and indentations in their mattresses, often in the middle, across several models.
Back Pain and Discomfort A widespread complaint of back pain, exacerbated by sagging and indentations, leading to poor sleeping posture.
Pressure Points and Uneven Support Failure in providing even support, causing pressure points and discomfort, particularly in models with dips or sags.
Health and Sleep Quality Concerns Issues like neuropathy and constant aching linked to poor support, leading to decreased sleep quality.
Comfort Discrepancy Mattresses felt comfortable in the showroom but failed to deliver the same comfort level upon delivery.
Quality and Durability Concerns Quick deterioration of mattress quality and durability despite the high price, disappointing buyers.
Customer Service and Warranty Challenges Challenges with customer service and warranty claims, often not honoured or difficult to claim.
High Price Not Reflecting Quality The high cost of the mattresses does not reflect the expected superior quality, leading to dissatisfaction.

Analysis of 276 Stearns and Foster mattresses reviews reveals a significant trend in customer dissatisfaction. The breakdown of these reviews is as follows:

Review Rating Number of Reviews
5-stars 20
4-stars 6
3-stars 6
2-stars 42
1 star 202

Out of the 276 Stearn and Foster mattress reviews analysed, 244 expressed dissatisfaction, showing that approximately 88% of reviewers were unhappy with their purchase.

It’s crucial to note that this feedback comes from just 276 reviews, a small portion of Stearns and Fosters’ annual sales. Hence, these views might not completely represent the overall product performance of Stearns and Foster.

At Winstons, a leading retailer of luxury handmade natural mattresses and bedding, we hold Stearns and Foster in high regard as a frontrunner in the foam mattress industry. We always encourage our customers to compare various brands to make informed decisions. We take pride in offering high-quality mattresses that provide excellent value. However, we understand that each customer has unique needs and preferences. We recommend thorough research and comparison of different brands and models to discover the perfect mattress that meets individual needs.

(Review data was sourced from and as of 30/01/24)

Stearns and Foster Reserve mattress reviews

Delving into customer experiences with the Stearns and Foster Reserve mattress, this analysis offers a straightforward look at what buyers have to say. We draw from authentic feedback posted on the Stearns and Foster website to offer you a clear picture of the mattress’s strengths and weaknesses.

Highlights from Stearns and Foster Reserve Reviews

The Upsides

  • Balanced Comfort: A number of users find the mattress perfectly balances firmness with plushness, delivering a sleep surface that caters well to diverse preferences. Satisfaction levels are high among those who chose the model that matched their comfort needs.

The Downsides

  • Firmness Discrepancies: A prevalent issue is the mattress’s unexpected firmness. Models labelled as soft or plush often feel too hard, leading to discomfort for some, particularly side sleepers and sometimes causing back pain.
  • Changes in Design and Quality: Long-time customers point out alterations in material and design from earlier models. The use of different fabrics and the addition of firm tufting knots have lessened comfort for several users.
  • Sagging Issues: There are concerns about the mattress’s longevity, with reports of sagging occurring within months of purchase. This has resulted in discomfort and worsened sleep quality for some.
    Heat Retention: Newer versions of the mattress appear to trap body heat more than their predecessors, making for an uncomfortably warm night’s sleep for certain buyers.

The Stearns and Foster Reserve mattress elicits mixed reactions. While many praise its quality and comfort, others are dissatisfied with its firmness, alterations in design, durability issues and tendency to retain heat. This analysis stresses the importance of selecting a mattress that aligns with personal comfort preferences and highlights the need for transparent product details.

Winstons Shropshire Mattress Vs Stearns and Foster Reserve Medium

Winstons ShropshireStearns & Foster Reserve Medum
Price$4299.99 US Queen Size (Including Shipping to Anywhere in USA)$4599.99 US Queen Size (Not Including Sales Taxes)
Filling CompositionEnglish Lambswool, British Pure Wool & Cotton, British Fleece Wool & Cotton, Hand Teased Shropshire Wool, Hand Teased Loose Long Curled Horsetail, British Highland Wool & Natural HessianMemory Foam, Micro Coils, Innerspring Coil Unit, Edge Support Coils, Foam Base
Filling Total GSM55000
Hand Side Stitching Rows30 - Machine Stitched
Spring Count1600 Calico Pocket Springs1744 Spunbond Innersprings & Micro Coils
Natural Fibre100% Natural0%
Trial45 Nights90 Nights
Guarantee30 Years10 Years

Why the Winstons Shropshire Mattress outshines the Stearns and Foster Reserve Medium mattress

When choosing a mattress, discerning buyers look beyond mere brand names, seeking quality, comfort and value. The comparison between the Winstons Shropshire mattress and the Stearns and Foster Reserve Medium mattress illustrates a clear distinction in what each offers, making the choice straightforward for those in the know.

The Winstons Shropshire Advantage

  • Craftsmanship and Materials: The Winstons Shropshire mattress embodies the pinnacle of mattress construction. Unlike the Reserve Medium, which is machine-made with synthetic layers and basic inner springs, the Shropshire is a testament to traditional craftsmanship. Each mattress is handmade and hand-stitched, featuring calico pocket springs and utilising 100% natural materials. This dedication to quality ensures not only superior comfort but also longevity.
  • Price and Value: Despite the superior craftsmanship of the Shropshire, it comes at a more affordable price than the Reserve Medium. This stark difference in pricing highlights the overvaluation of the Reserve Medium. For a mattress that relies on mass production techniques and incorporates synthetic materials, its price point is not justified when compared to the meticulously crafted, all-natural Shropshire.
  • Comfort and Support: The Shropshire’s use of calico pocket springs offers unparalleled support and comfort, adapting seamlessly to the sleeper’s body without the common pitfalls of cheaper spring systems. The natural materials used in the Shropshire not only enhance sleep quality but also promote better health through improved air circulation and moisture control.
  • Durability: Handmade with attention to detail, the Shropshire is built to last. Its construction starkly contrasts with the Reserve Medium’s reliance on lower-quality, synthetic components that can degrade more quickly over time.
  • Environmental and Health Considerations: With an increasing awareness of the impact of synthetic materials on both health and the environment, the Shropshire’s commitment to using 100% natural materials stands out. Consumers are becoming more conscious of the benefits of natural materials, not only for their own health but also for the sustainability of our planet.

In conclusion, while the Stearns and Foster Reserve Medium mattress may appeal to those unaware of the nuances of mattress quality and construction, a closer inspection and comparison with the Winstons Shropshire mattress reveal a clear winner. The Shropshire offers unmatched craftsmanship, natural materials and overall value, making it the superior choice for discerning buyers. The fact that such a premium product comes from England at a lower price point only further underscores the overpricing and underwhelming value proposition of the Reserve Medium. For those seeking the best in comfort, durability and value, the choice is unmistakably the Winstons Shropshire mattress.

Winstons Highland Pillow Top Mattress Vs Stearns & Foster Reserve Soft Pillow Top Mattress

Winstons HighlandStearns & Foster Reserve Soft PT
Price$5499,99 US Queen Size (Including Shipping to Anywhere in USA)$5299.99 US Queen Size (Not Including Sales Taxes)
Filling CompositionEnglish Lambswool, Pure Wool & Cotton, British Fleece Wool & Cotton, Hand Teased Shropshire Wool, Hand Teased Loose Long Curled Horsetail, British Highland Wool, Natural Hessian, English Lambswool, Hand Teased Shropshire Wool, Hand Teased Cotton & British Highland WoolMemory Foam, Micro Coils, Innerspring Coil Unit, Edge Support Coils, Foam Base
Filling Total GSM95000
Hand Side Stitching Rows30 - Machine Stitched
Spring Count1600 Calico Pocket Springs1744 Spunbond Innersprings & Micro Coils
Natural Fibre100% Natural0%
Trial45 Nights90 Nights
Guarantee30 Years10 Years

Choosing the Winstons Highland mattress over the Stearns and Foster Reserve Soft pillow top

For those in search of the perfect night’s sleep, the decision often boils down to quality, craftsmanship and value. A side-by-side look at the Winstons Highland mattress and the Stearns and Foster Reserve Soft Pillow Top mattress reveals why the former far surpasses the latter.

Advantages of the Winstons Highland Mattress

  • Exceptional Craftsmanship: The Winstons Highland mattress exemplifies the best in traditional mattress making. Unlike the Reserve Soft Pillow Top, which is produced en masse using synthetic components, each Highland mattress benefits from careful, handcrafted construction. Its calico pocket springs provide unmatched support and durability, qualities not found in machine-made mattresses.
  • Natural vs. Synthetic Materials: The Highland mattress’s reliance on premium natural fibres starkly contrasts with the synthetic foam used in the Reserve Soft Pillow Top. These natural materials enhance sleep by offering superior breathability and reducing the risk of exposure to harmful chemicals. They also contribute to the mattress’s impressive durability and overall comfort.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: Despite its higher quality and handcrafted nature, the Highland mattress is only slightly higher priced than its Stearns and Foster counterpart. This discrepancy underscores the inflated price of the Reserve mattress, which fails to justify its synthetic and mass-produced makeup. The fact that the Highland comes from England and still offers better value highlights the excessive pricing of the Reserve mattress even further.
  • Superior Spring System: The Highland’s calico pocket springs adapt to the body’s contours, providing a level of support and comfort that spunbond innersprings and micro coils cannot match. This personalised support system is absent in mass-produced mattresses.
  • Hand Stitching Over Machine Stitching: The Highland mattress’s hand-stitched construction not only enhances its visual appeal but also its structural integrity. Hand stitching ensures a more durable border and shape retention over time, a benefit not achievable with machine-stitched mattresses like the Reserve Soft Pillow Top.

The comparison between the Winstons Highland and the Stearns and Foster Reserve Soft Pillow Top mattress is telling. It showcases the unmatched value, quality and craftsmanship of the Highland. Thanks to its use of natural materials, hand-stitched construction and superior spring system, the Highland mattress delivers a sleep experience that the Reserve Soft Pillow Top, with its synthetic materials and production methods, simply cannot rival. For those prioritising comfort, health and value, the Winstons Highland mattress stands out as the clear leader.

Stearns and Foster Reserve Duet reviews

Exploring customer feedback on the Stearns and Foster Reserve Duet mattress, this review provides a direct overview of user experiences. Drawing from genuine testimonials on the Stearns and Foster website, we aim to present a balanced assessment of the mattress’s pros and cons.

Highlights from Reserve Duet Foster and Stearns mattress reviews

The Upsides

  • Comfort Balance: Many users appreciate the mattress’s ability to strike a balance between firmness and support. Satisfaction levels are high among those who found the model that suits their comfort preferences.

The Downsides

  • Firmness Concerns: A prevalent issue is the unexpected firmness of the mattress, especially in models labelled as soft or plush. This has led to discomfort, particularly for side sleepers and sometimes results in back pain.
  • Design and Quality Changes: Long-term customers have noted alterations in materials and design from previous models. Changes like different fabrics and the addition of firm tufting knots have reduced comfort for some users.
  • Sagging Problems: Concerns have arisen regarding the mattress’s longevity, with reports of sagging occurring within a few months of purchase. This has caused discomfort and affected sleep quality for certain users.
  • Heat Retention: The mattress seems to retain body heat, leading to uncomfortably warm nights for some buyers.

The Stearns and Foster Reserve Duet mattress receives mixed reviews. While some users praise its quality and comfort, others express dissatisfaction with its firmness, design changes, durability issues and tendency to retain heat. This review emphasises the importance of choosing a mattress that suits individual comfort preferences and underscores the need for clear product information.

Winstons Grand Luxe Mattress Vs Stearns and Foster Reserve Duet Mattress

Winstons Grand LuxeStearns & Foster Reserve Duet
Price$6799.99 US Queen Size (Including Shipping to Anywhere in USA)$6299.99 US Queen Size (Not Including Sales Taxes)
Filling CompositionEnglish Lambswool, British Fleece Wool & Cotton, Hand Teased Silk, Hand Teased Alpaca Wool, Hand Teased Shropshire Wool, Hand Teased Long Loose Curled Horsetail, British Highland Wool & Organic FlaxMemory Foam, Micro Coils, Innerspring Coil Unit, Edge Support Coils, Foam Base
Filling Total GSM67500
Hand Side Stitching Rows50 - Machine Stitched
Spring Count3000 Calico Pocket Springs1744 Spunbond Innersprings & Micro Coils
Natural Fibre100% Natural0%
Trial45 Nights90 Nights
Guarantee30 Years10 Years

Why choose the Winstons Grand Luxe mattress over the Stearns and Foster Reserve Duet mattress

When it comes to investing in a mattress, making the right choice is crucial for a good night’s sleep. Let’s delve deeper into why opting for the Winstons Grand Luxe mattress is a clear winner over the Stearns and Foster Reserve Duet mattress.

Value for Money: The Winstons Grand Luxe may come at a slightly higher price of $6799.99, but it offers unparalleled value compared to the synthetic and machine-made Stearns and Foster Reserve Duet, priced at $6299.99. Investing a little more for a vastly superior sleeping experience is a wise decision in the long run.

Quality of Materials: The Grand Luxe mattress is crafted using the crème de la crème of natural fillings, including English Lambswool, British Fleece Wool & Cotton, Hand-Teased Silk, Hand-Teased Alpaca Wool, Hand-Teased Shropshire Wool, Hand-Teased Long Loose Curled Horsetail, British Highland Wool & Organic Flax. In stark contrast, the Reserve Duet mattress relies on synthetic foam layers and spunbond innersprings, which simply cannot match the luxury and comfort offered by natural materials.

Luxurious Springs: With 3000 calico pocket springs, the Grand Luxe provides unparalleled support and comfort. These premium springs adapt to your body shape, ensuring a restful night’s sleep every time. Meanwhile, the Reserve Duet mattress falls short with its inferior inner spring system, unable to deliver the same level of support and durability.

Handcrafted Luxury: Handcrafted to perfection, the Grand Luxe exudes luxury in every stitch. Each mattress is meticulously crafted by skilled artisans, ensuring unparalleled attention to detail and quality. On the other hand, the Reserve Duet mattress is mass-produced, lacking the bespoke craftsmanship and luxurious feel of a handcrafted mattress

How can you buy a mattress from Winstons Beds?

To buy your chosen mattress from Winston’s, please follow the straightforward steps below.

After selecting your favourite models from our collection, email us at [email protected]. Include the following information in your email:

  • Your name
  • Your billing address
  • The shipping address for the mattress
  • Your contact phone number
  • Your email address for communication
  • The size of the mattress you need
  • The model of the mattress you’ve chosen
  • Your preferred spring tension in the mattress
  • Once we receive your details, we’ll issue an online invoice for secure payment.
  • After processing your payment, you’ll get an order confirmation, and we’ll start the production of your mattress.

Delivery Timeline

We’ll inform you when your mattress is ready to ship. Our delivery partner, DHL, will then reach out to schedule a convenient delivery time and date with you.

We strive to dispatch your mattress within 8 weeks from the payment date. With DHL’s efficient service, expect your mattress to arrive at your doorstep in the USA within 5 working days from its dispatch date from our factory.


Stearns & Foster, established in 1846 in Cincinnati, Ohio, is a long-standing mattress company with a history that spans over a century. Founded by George S. Stearns and Seth C. Foster, the company initially focused on manufacturing cotton goods before pivoting to mattress production. This shift marked the beginning of Stearns & Foster's journey in the bedding industry.

In the early stages, Stearns & Foster was recognised for its innovation in using cotton felt in mattresses. This material choice was a departure from the traditional materials used in mattress manufacturing at the time and represented a new approach to mattress construction. The company's adoption of cotton felt was driven by a desire to explore different materials that could offer different qualities in mattress production.

As the years progressed, Stearns & Foster continued to evolve. The company introduced new materials and techniques in their manufacturing processes. A significant development in their product line was the use of individually wrapped coil systems. This technology aimed to provide a different kind of support and reduce motion transfer in mattresses.

Throughout the 20th century, Stearns & Foster expanded its operations and product offerings, adapting to changing market trends and consumer preferences. Their approach to mattress manufacturing involved various traditional methods, including some handcrafted elements.

In more recent years, Stearns & Foster became a part of Tempur Sealy International, a larger entity in the bedding industry. This acquisition expanded the brand's distribution channels, allowing their mattresses to be available in more locations globally.

Stearns & Foster's history is characterised by its early innovation in materials and a gradual evolution of its product line. Their approach to mattress manufacturing has varied over the years, reflecting changes in technology and consumer expectations.

For a more detailed understanding of Stearns & Foster's history and operations, information was gathered from historical archives and the official Stearns & Foster website. These sources provide an overview of the company's journey from its early days to its current status in the bedding industry.
Stearns & Foster is owned by Tempur Sealy International, a significant player in the global bedding market. This ownership links Stearns & Foster to a wider network of mattress technology and distribution. Tempur Sealy International, known for its innovation in the sleep industry, acquired Stearns & Foster to broaden its range of high-quality bedding products. This move has placed Stearns & Foster within a larger portfolio of reputable mattress brands, enhancing its reach and influence in the market.

(This information is based on the latest corporate details available from Tempur Sealy International's official communications and industry reports)
Stearns & Foster mattresses are made by Tempur Sealy International.
Stearns & Foster mattresses are primarily made in the United States.
Stearns & Foster mattresses, while of good quality, are not crafted as luxury items. Their manufacturing process reflects a more standard approach in the industry. It typically starts with laying a base layer of foam or polyester. Then, pre-made mass-manufactured spunbond pocket coils are placed on this base. Layers of foam are added on top of these springs. The mattress is then bordered and a knit cover is applied over the top and tape-edged to the border. The mattress is flipped, another cover is added to the bottom and it's tape-edged again. This method, primarily machine-based, is efficient but lacks the bespoke craftsmanship of luxury mattresses.

In contrast, Our handmade mattresses exemplify true luxury, distinct from standard manufacturing processes like those used by Stearns & Foster. In our mattresses, each component reflects craftsmanship and attention to detail. We use calico springs, each meticulously hand-tied with twine by skilled artisans. This method ensures superior support and durability, as the springs are individually secured, allowing for more precise tension control.

Furthermore, the border of our mattresses is completely hand-stitched. This painstaking process not only adds to the aesthetic appeal but also contributes to the mattress's overall structural integrity. Hand stitching provides a level of durability and quality that machine stitching simply cannot match.

Our mattresses also feature hand-teased fillings. This involves separating and fluffing up the fibres, which enhances the loft and breathability of the mattress. Hand-teasing ensures an even distribution of fillings, resulting in a mattress that provides consistent support and comfort throughout. It's a time-consuming process, but it's crucial for creating a mattress that offers a luxurious sleeping experience.

These elements - hand-tied calico springs, hand-stitched borders and hand-teased fillings - collectively define the luxury of our mattresses. Each step is carried out with utmost care, setting our products apart from mid-range options and highlighting the stark contrast in quality and craftsmanship.

The difference between these two methods is significant. Handmade mattresses, like ours, are labour-intensive and require skilled craftsmanship, often resulting in a more luxurious, personalised product.

In contrast, the more automated process used by Stearns & Foster, while efficient and consistent, doesn't provide the same level of bespoke luxury. The distinction lies in the attention to detail, the quality of materials and the craftsmanship involved in the production process.
Stearns and Foster mattresses come with a 10-year warranty, suggesting confidence in their longevity and quality. However, customer reviews highlight concerns about durability, indicating that the lifespan may not always reach the decade mark.

This discrepancy between the warranty period and user experience can raise questions about value, especially considering the premium pricing of these mattresses, which feature high-density foam and encased coils. It's important to note that mattress lifespan can vary based on several factors, including usage and maintenance. While the brand promises luxury and comfort, potential buyers should weigh these aspects carefully.
Stearns and Foster mattresses have faced issues with sagging, as pointed out in customer reviews. This sagging can occur for several reasons.

Firstly, the foam may compress over time under body weight, leading to indentations.

Secondly, micro coils, designed to provide support and adapt to body contours, can lose their resilience with continuous pressure. It's crucial for buyers to consider these factors, along with how they use and maintain the mattress, to mitigate sagging.
You cannot flip a Stearns and Foster mattress, as they design their mattresses to be one-sided. This design choice means the comfort layers are only on the top side, with the bottom side intended to rest on the base or frame. This setup can be seen as a drawback for several reasons.

Firstly, flipping a mattress can help distribute wear more evenly, potentially extending its life. Without the ability to flip, wear concentrates on one side, possibly leading to quicker degradation.

Secondly, considering the high cost of Stearns and Foster mattresses, the inability to flip may not offer the best value for money. Customers expect durability and longevity from premium products and one-sided mattresses might fall short in maximising lifespan compared to flippable alternatives.
In assessing whether Stearns and Foster mattresses offer value for money, it's essential to consider the materials and construction methods used. Stearns and Foster mattresses utilise foam, spunbond innersprings and micro coils, materials that, while innovative, are relatively inexpensive to produce.

Additionally, the manufacturing process for these mattresses, despite the premium branding, does not significantly differ in skill level required compared to other mattresses in the market. Given the high price point of Stearns and Foster mattresses, the question of value arises. When you compare the cost of production and the selling price, there appears to be a substantial markup. This discrepancy suggests that the price may not fully reflect the material cost and manufacturing complexity.

Therefore, from a professional standpoint, Stearns and Foster mattresses may not offer the best value for money. Consumers are encouraged to explore the market thoroughly, considering both the material qualities and manufacturing process of various brands. This approach helps ensure that the chosen mattress offers both comfort and durability, aligning with the buyer's expectations and investment.
Stearns and Foster mattresses, in our view, are good in terms of quality and comfort. However, when considering their high price point, we believe they do not offer the best value for money. The core materials used in these mattresses—foam, micro coils and spunbond innersprings—are relatively inexpensive to produce. This fact raises questions about the premium pricing strategy adopted by Stearns and Foster, which positions these mattresses as luxury items.

The brand's portrayal of these mattresses as luxury products does not fully align with the cost of their components. If priced more fairly, reflecting the actual materials and manufacturing process, Stearns and Foster mattresses could indeed represent good value. In their current pricing model, though, it's challenging to justify them as luxury mattresses offering superior value compared to other options available in the market.
There are no FAQs matching your search

Published: 30th January 2024 (Updated: 14th February 2024) | Isaah

Compare Mattresses
Sleep Tips
Sleep Trouble
  • Guarantee Icon

    Member of the FHIO

    Government-approved dispute resolution service for consumers to help reach a fair outcome.

  • Approved Icon

    Made By Approved NBF Member

    Have peace of mind that the mattress you are buying is safe, clean and exactly what it says it is.

  • British Icon

    British Heritage

    Mattresses made by artisans with over 95 years of britsh handcrafting heritage.